Category: 4/ Fellow”s Projects

Aula Fellow Project

  • Reconciling methodological paradigms: Employing large language models as novice qualitative research assistants in talent management research

    Reconciling methodological paradigms: Employing large language models as novice qualitative research assistants in talent management research

    Qualitative data collection and analysis approaches, such as those employing interviews and focus groups, provide rich insights into customer attitudes, sentiment, and behavior. However, manually analyzing qualitative data requires extensive time and effort to identify relevant topics and thematic insights. This study proposes a novel approach to address this challenge by leveraging Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) based Large Language Models (LLMs) for analyzing interview transcripts. The novelty of this work lies in strategizing the research inquiry as one that is augmented by an LLM that serves as a novice research assistant. This research explores the mental model of LLMs to serve as novice qualitative research assistants for researchers in the talent management space. A RAG-based LLM approach is extended to enable topic modeling of semi-structured interview data, showcasing the versatility of these models beyond their traditional use in information retrieval and search. Our findings demonstrate that the LLM-augmented RAG approach can successfully extract topics of interest, with significant coverage compared to manually generated topics from the same dataset. This establishes the viability of employing LLMs as novice qualitative research assistants. Additionally, the study recommends that researchers leveraging such models lean heavily on quality criteria used in traditional qualitative research to ensure rigor and trustworthiness of their approach. Finally, the paper presents key recommendations for industry practitioners seeking to reconcile the use of LLMs with established qualitative research paradigms, providing a roadmap for the effective integration of these powerful, albeit novice, AI tools in the analysis of qualitative datasets within talent

    More Information

  • Toward a trustworthy and inclusive data governance policy for the use of artificial intelligence in Africa

    Toward a trustworthy and inclusive data governance policy for the use of artificial intelligence in Africa

    This article proposes five ideas that the design of data governance policies for the trustworthy use of artificial intelligence (AI) in Africa should consider. The first is for African states to assess their domestic strategic priorities, strengths, and weaknesses. The second is a human-centric approach to data governance, which involves data processing practices that protect the security of personal data and the privacy of data subjects; ensure that personal data are processed in a fair, lawful, and accountable manner; minimize the harmful effect of personal data misuse or abuse on data subjects and other victims; and promote a beneficial, trusted use of personal data. The third is for the data policy to be in alignment with supranational rights-respecting AI standards like the African Charter on Human and Peoples Rights, the AU Convention on Cybersecurity, and Personal Data Protection. The fourth is for states to be critical about the extent to which AI systems can be relied on in certain public sectors or departments. The fifth and final proposition is for the need to prioritize the use of representative and interoperable data and ensure a transparent procurement process for AI systems from abroad where no local options exist.

    More Information

  • Collision Toronto: Booth

    Collision Toronto: Booth

    Emmanuel Taiwo and Tammy Mackenzie represented the Aula Fellowship in the social good start-up stage. Thank you, Collision Toronto, for this excellent experience with old and new friends, working for good AI together in excellent company. Thanks also to Aula Fellow Rubaina Khan, Victoria Kuketz, and Marisa Eleuterio, for technical support throughout!

    More Information

  • Collision Toronto: Presentation

    Collision Toronto: Presentation

    Presented the Aula Fellowship from the Non-Profits Stage. Thank you, Victoria!

    More Information

  • Digitization and Political Participation in the MENA Region: Egypt, Kuwait, and Tunisia

    Digitization and Political Participation in the MENA Region: Egypt, Kuwait, and Tunisia

    The article highlights the link between digitization and political participation in three Middle Eastern countries: Egypt, Kuwait, and Tunisia. The role of the Internet and social media in political engagement is thoroughly discussed from a historical-comparative perspective. Using micro and macro level data, the study analyzes the usage of new online technologies and online political participation.
    The findings provide valuable insights for understanding the intricate nature of online political participation and the paradox between digital engagement and traditional political involvement. Despite the expansion of digital media, traditional political interest and participation has decreased. Egypt and Kuwait demonstrate advanced stages of digitization with widespread Internet access, while Tunisia’s progress is varied.

    More Information

  • OECD Gender Equality in Technology Governance

    OECD Gender Equality in Technology Governance

    Director Mackenzie represented the Aula Fellowship and the AI context in conversations at this global conference for equity. We stand together, or we fall.

    More Information

  • Exploring and Expanding Support for International Students in Engineering: Faculty Reflections Beyond Academic Boundaries

    Exploring and Expanding Support for International Students in Engineering: Faculty Reflections Beyond Academic Boundaries

    This is a student paper:

    Expanding upon our previous work in the blinded for review paper, this research seeks to delve into the realm of self-reflection among engineering faculty members who regularly interact with international students. The primary objective is to investigate how these faculty members address the unique needs of the international student community. The Challenge and Support model by Nevitt Sanford serves as our guiding framework for this research, and we employ narrative analysis due to its potential in analyzing differences in cases and describing the dynamics of individual narratives within their distinct contexts (Floersch et al., 2010; Simons et al., 2008).

    This paper aims to answer the following research question: How do engineering faculty members address the multifaceted and distinct needs of international students? It is important to understand these perspectives when considering how to support international engineering students given that each student has unique and intricate experiences in both academic and non-academic aspects.

    More Information

  • Investigating Transition Phases: An Autoethnographic Study of International Women of Color Engineering Educators in the US

    Investigating Transition Phases: An Autoethnographic Study of International Women of Color Engineering Educators in the US

    The study aims to explore the transitions experienced by international Women of Color (IWoC) engineers in the US as they navigate their academic and professional lives. Motivated by the lack of research on IWoC’s experiences, specifically around transition points of their lives, four international Women of Color participated in this qualitative auto-ethnographic deep-dive. All four researchers have attended college in the United States for their high educational degrees focused on education/engineering education and are currently involved in engineering education scholarship work.

    More Information

  • Making Space for Critical Action: Re-visioning Computational Thinking

    Making Space for Critical Action: Re-visioning Computational Thinking

    While school makerspaces promise to inspire and excite, the challenge of meaningfully integrating them into schools remains. Guided by a philosophy of praxis that stresses the need for education to interweave theory, action, and reflection to advance positive social change in our communities (Freire, 1970), this paper reports on the co-design of a school space called the Critical Action Learning Lab (CALL) for inclusive making to support computational thinking and critical action through curriculum-informed learning

    More Information

  • Outsiders: Pathways and Perspectives from Engineering Education PhDs Outside Academia

    Outsiders: Pathways and Perspectives from Engineering Education PhDs Outside Academia

    This article presents a critical exploration and recommendation based on the lived experiences of PhD graduates in Engineering Education who have ventured into non-academic career paths. The work is rooted in an auto-ethnographic research approach, and the report aims to mimic a live virtual panel. It seeks to elucidate the experiences and challenges faced by PhD graduates who diverged from traditional academic roles to pursue careers in industry, entrepreneurship, consulting, and pre-college leadership. These narratives reveal a complex landscape of motivations, perceived hierarchical barriers, and under-recognition within academic and non-academic sectors, highlighting a divide between industry and academia. The paper delves into the unique challenges faced by non-academic engineering educators, such as confronting a culture that often questions their value outside traditional faculty roles and the overarching perception that non-research roles are less significant. Despite these challenges, the authors argue for the vital role these professionals play in bridging the gap between research, instruction, and practical application in engineering education. They emphasize the importance of ASEE or similar professional societies in recognizing and leveraging the diverse contributions of non-academic engineering educators to foster a more inclusive and supportive community. Key takeaways and recommendations include the necessity for ASEE and similar bodies to shift normative expectations, create inclusive and equitable environments, and actively value diverse career trajectories. The paper calls for actionable strategies to build more inclusive professional communities, create safe spaces for discussing career diversity, and establish stronger connections between current students and diverse alums. The overarching goal is to cultivate an environment where all forms of contribution to engineering education are valued, encouraging a broader spectrum of career considerations among graduates and professionals. The authors seek not only to share insights but also to galvanize a nascent community of like-minded engineering educators aspiring or working outside the traditional academic sphere.

    More Information

  • Reimagining AI Conference Mission Statements to Promote Inclusion in the Emerging Institutional Field of AI

    Reimagining AI Conference Mission Statements to Promote Inclusion in the Emerging Institutional Field of AI

    AI conferences play a crucial role in education by providing a platform for knowledge sharing, networking, and collaboration, shaping the future of AI research and applications, and informing curricula and teaching practices. This work-in-progress, innovative practice paper presents preliminary findings from textual analysis of mission statements from select artificial intelligence (AI) conferences to uncover information gaps and opportunities that hinder inclusivity and accessibility in the emerging institutional field of AI. By examining language and focus, we identify potential barriers to entry for individuals interested in the AI domain, including educators, researchers, practitioners, and students from underrepresented groups. Our paper employs the use of the Language as Symbolic Action (LSA) framework [1] to reveal information gaps in areas such as no explicit emphasis on DEI, undefined promises of business and personal empowerment and power, and occasional elitism. These preliminary findings uncover opportunities for improvement, including the need for more inclusive language, an explicit commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, clearer communications about conference goals and expectations, and emphasis on strategies to address power imbalances and promote equal opportunities for participation. The impact of our work is bi-fold: 1) we demonstrate preliminary results from using the Language as Symbolic Action framework to text-analysis of mission statements, and 2) our preliminary findings will be valuable to the education community in understanding gaps in current AI conferences and consequently, outreach. Our work is thus of practical use for conference organizers, engineering and CS educators and other AI-related domains, researchers, and the broader AI community. Our paper highlights the need for more intentional and inclusive conference design to foster a diverse and vibrant community and community of AI professionals.

    More Information

  • Teaching Future-Makers: Outcomes of an International Design Workshop for Critical Action Educators

    Teaching Future-Makers: Outcomes of an International Design Workshop for Critical Action Educators

    This paper reports on recent developments of the Critical Action Learning Exchange (Carvalho et al., 2021), an international community of educators who seek to respond to social and environmental issues that affect their students. We report on an international design workshop that engaged a cohort of teachers in designing Critical Action Learning activities for their students in the Summer of 2023. Participants (n=39) completed 16 curriculum designs for grade levels from kindergarten to university, addressing a broad range of socio-environmental issues and adopting diverse approaches, such as Arts-Based Critical Action, Community Engagement, Critical Making, Games for Critical Action, and Storytelling. This paper examines our Professional Development model, together with an analysis of teacher participants’ ideas and their design products. We investigate what forms of scaffolding can facilitate the changes of practice needed for teachers to become critical action educators and support their Critical Action Learning designs.

    More Information